Two Arrows:

How We Can Choose to Suffer Less

 

Life throws a lot our way, doesn't it?  From stubbing your toe to navigating a difficult conversation at work, or even experiencing the profound grief of loss, pain is an undeniable part of the human experience.  But have you ever noticed how sometimes the pain of an event seems to linger, multiply, or even feel worse than the initial event itself? This is where the ancient Buddhist teaching of the "first and second arrow" offers profound wisdom for cultivating mindfulness and, ultimately, reducing our suffering.

 

The First Arrow: The Inevitable Pain

 

Imagine you're walking along, lost in thought, and suddenly, thwack!  You trip and fall, scraping your knee.  That initial impact, the sting, the surprise – that's the first arrow.

​

The first arrow represents the unavoidable, inherent pain of life.  It’s the physical sensation of an injury, the initial pang of disappointment when something doesn't go your way, the discomfort of an illness, or the sadness that arises from loss.  These are the things that happen to us, often outside of our control.  We can't always prevent the first arrow from striking.

 

The Second Arrow: The Self-Inflicted Suffering

 

Now, let's go back to that scraped knee.  After the initial sting, what often happens next?

​

Perhaps you start to think: "Oh, I'm so clumsy!  Why do I always do this?  This is going to ruin my day.  I can't believe I was so careless."  Or you might start to feel angry, frustrated, or even ashamed.  You might dwell on the pain, catastrophize the situation, or replay it endlessly in your mind.

​

This is the second arrow.

​

The second arrow is the suffering we add on top of the initial pain.  It's our reaction, our resistance, our judgment, our rumination, our self-criticism, and our emotional distress about the pain.  While the first arrow is often unavoidable, the second arrow is largely optional.  It's the story we tell ourselves about the first arrow, and it’s the way we choose to respond to it.

​

Why Do We Shoot Ourselves with the Second Arrow?

 

It’s a natural human tendency.  Our minds are wired to make sense of things, to problem-solve, and sometimes, to protect us by dwelling on perceived threats.  However, this often leads us down a path of compounding our own suffering.  We get stuck in cycles of worry, regret, and self-blame, transforming a momentary discomfort into prolonged anguish.

 

Cultivating Mindfulness: Choosing Not to Shoot the Second Arrow

 

The good news is that understanding the first and second arrow empowers us to choose a different path.  This is where mindfulness comes in.  Mindfulness is the practice of bringing our attention to the present moment, observing our thoughts, feelings, and bodily sensations without judgment.

​

Here's how we can apply this teaching:

1. Acknowledge the First Arrow: When pain arises (physical or emotional), simply acknowledge it.  "This is discomfort.  This is sadness.  This is anger."  Notice the raw sensation without immediately layering on a narrative.

2. Pause and Observe Your Reaction: Before reacting, take a breath.  What thoughts are arising?  What emotions are emerging?  Are you adding judgment, blame, or future-oriented worry?  Notice these as "second arrows" in the making.

3. Choose Your Response: This is the crucial step.  Instead of automatically firing the second arrow, can you gently unhook from those reactive thoughts and emotions?  Can you bring kindness and compassion to the first arrow instead?

   • If you're physically hurt, focus on what you need to do to care for the injury, rather than berating yourself for being clumsy.

   • If you're feeling disappointed, acknowledge the disappointment without letting it spiral into self-criticism or despair.

   • If you're grieving, allow the sadness to be present without judging it or trying to push it away.

​​

The Freedom of Choice

 

The teaching of the first and second arrow isn't about avoiding pain – that's impossible.  It's about recognizing that we have a profound choice in how much we suffer.  By becoming aware of the second arrow, we gain the power to release ourselves from its grip.  We learn to be present with what is, to respond with wisdom rather than reactivity, and in doing so, to dramatically lessen the unnecessary suffering in our lives.

​

So, the next time life throws a dart your way, remember the two arrows.  Feel the sting of the first, but consciously choose not to shoot the second.  Your mind, body, and spirit will thank you.

​

"In life, we can’t always control the first arrow.  However, the second arrow is our reaction to the first.  This second arrow is optional."

- Pema Chödrön